- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
Criteria in diagnosing nocturnal leg cramps: a systematic review
BMC Family Practicevolume 18, Article number: 29 (2017)
Up to 33% of the general population over 50 years of age are affected by nocturnal leg cramps. Currently there are no generally accepted clinical characteristics, which identify nocturnal leg cramps. This study aims to identify these clinical characteristics and to differentiate between them and the characteristics of restless leg syndrome and periodic limb disorder.
A systematic literature study was executed from December 2015 to May 2016. This study comprised of a systematic literature review of randomized clinical trials, observational studies on nocturnal and rest cramps of legs and other muscles, and other systematic and narrative reviews. Two researchers independently extracted literature data and analyzed this using a standardized reviewing protocol. Modified versions of the Cochrane Collaboration tools assessed the risk of bias. A Delphi study was conducted to assess agreement on the characteristics of nocturnal leg cramps.
After systematic and manual searches, eight randomized trials and ten observational studies were included. On the basis of these we identified seven diagnostic characteristics of nocturnal leg cramps: intense pain, period of duration from seconds to maximum 10 minutes, location in calf or foot, location seldom in thigh or hamstrings, persistent subsequent pain, sleep disruption and distress.
The seven above characteristics will enhance recognition of the condition, and help clinicians make a clear distinction between NLC and other sleep-related musculoskeletal disorder among older adults.
Nocturnal Leg Cramps (NLC) is a musculoskeletal disorder characterized by suddenly occurring, episodic, persistently painful, involuntary contractions of the calf, hamstrings or foot muscles at night . Up to 33% of the general population over 50 years of age have complaints related to NLC . In 20% of these cases, cramps also occur during rest periods in the daytime . Sleep disturbances, which may seriously affect well-being and quality of life, are common among patients with NLC [4, 5]. Symptoms, as well as prevalence and incidence, progress with advancing age [1, 6]. There is no consensus about aetiology of NLC, however it is suggested that shortened muscle length among older less physically active people is a risk factor . Medical pathologies associated with NLC are chronic liver and renal failure (haemodialysis), vascular diseases, magnesium or calcium deficiency, dehydration and varicose veins [2, 7]. A pre-stretching protocol by physical therapists, as well as medical treatment blocking the medial branch of the deep peroneal nerve after lumbar surgery, may be effective in treating NLC [8, 9].
In contrast to the restless leg syndrome (RLS) and the idiopathic periodic limb movement disorder (PLMD), diagnosing NLC is hindered due to lack of a categorical definition of NLC. Moreover, different types of muscular cramps such as idiopathic, rest, leg, or pregnancy-related cramps are similar to NLC symptoms and are often confused in the literature .
Diagnostic criteria for RLS are clearly stated as follows: uncomfortable and unpleasant sensations in the legs, feet or arms associated with an urge to move; relief of symptoms by moving the affected limb; occurrence during rest in the evening or at night [11, 12]. The International Restless Leg Syndrome Study Group approved the validity of a rating scale for RLS, which reflects the severity of the discomfort . Idiopathic PLMD symptoms include the repetitive jerking movements of the leg for approximately 20-30 seconds during sleep, with the complaints when awake being more intense than during sleep. PLMD can be classified into mild, moderate, and severe levels as measured by the Periodic Limb Movement Index. Additionally, both RLS and PLMD may co-exist . No consensus has been reached regarding the diagnostic criteria for NLC, or how to differentiate them from the RLS and PLMD criteria . Primarily based on the patient history, the diagnosis of NLC may be confused with RLS or PLMD .
Generally, nocturnal pain can be a symptom of a serious pathology such as Parkinson disease, cardiovascular and renal diseases, lumbar canal stenosis, osteroarthritis, peripheral neuropathy or cirrhosis. It is important to differentially diagnose NLC when is present as a nonspecific musculoskeletal disorder, or related to serious pathology.
This study focuses on strengthening the available criteria in order to prevent the misdiagnosis of NLC, for RLS or PLMD. The first aim of this literature review is to identify characteristics for diagnosing NLC. The second aim is to differentiate these diagnostic characteristics from other sleep-related disorders, such as RLS and PLMD, for application in clinical care.
A systematic review was done to identify diagnostic criteria of NLC. The methodology is specified in our PROSPERO-registered protocol (16467) and conforms to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines . In order to differentiate between NLC, on the one hand, and RLS and PLMD, on the other, an additional Delphi methodology was used. In this study a focus group of 27 experts assessed the relevance of the diagnostic criteria.
An experienced librarian assisted in the development of a search strategy to identify recognized terminology. Four electronic databases were used including MEDLINE, Cinahl, EMBASE and PEDro (1990 to May 2016).
The search included all commonly used terms for NLC such as ‘cramps’, ‘muscle cramps’, ‘nocturnal leg cramps’, ‘leg cramps’, ‘night leg cramps’, ‘rest cramps’, ‘sleep-wake transition disorders/classification’, ‘aged’, ‘aging’, ‘elderly’, ‘senior’, ‘diagnosis’, ‘classification’, ‘epidemiology’, ‘rehabilitation’, ‘parasomnias’, ‘clinical trial’, ‘randomized controlled trial’, ‘observational study’, ‘clinical study’, ‘systematic review’, ‘meta-analysis’, ‘validation study’ or ‘letter’.
Inclusion criteria included randomised clinical trials, or observational studies reflecting NLC, muscle cramp, leg cramp, or rest cramp. The studies had to use the diagnostic criteria and classification in older adults aged over 50 years. A time frame spanning the previous 25 years.
Studies with non-English abstracts were excluded.
Two authors (JMH and MHGdG) independently extracted, screened, and reviewed all titles and abstracts of the retrieved articles. The articles were interpreted and classified into randomised clinical trials and observational studies. Reference lists of any recent reviews were hand searched in order to identify additional studies and help in excluding any duplicates.
The characteristics, diagnostic features and population characteristics of the investigated populations were summarised and catalogued. Randomised clinical trials and observational studies were screened for descriptions of diagnostic terms or classification criteria for NLC during sleep among adults aged over 50. For each included study, descriptive data regarding the participants and diagnostic terms were extracted. A flowchart was made to show the process of the literature search .
Cochrane checklists for randomised clinical trials and observational studies were appraised using the methodological quality (risk of bias) of the included studies. To discuss any discrepancies between the two reviewers, consensus meetings were arranged. Complete agreement was reached after discussions with a third reviewer (CvdS) in all of the cases.
The Delphi methodology was performed to examine the relevance of the extracted diagnostic criteria found in the systematic review. A questionnaire with closed-ended questions on a five-point Likert scale (always – mostly – sometimes – never - not known) was presented to a focus group of experts. The questionnaire was developed based on the results of the literature search and comprised the following items: (1) Are you known with NLC; (2) NLC has a sudden onset; (3) NLC is only present at night; (4) Pain and/or intense pain is the main characteristic; (5) NLC duration varies from seconds to 10 minutes; (6) NLC location is thigh, calf or foot; (7) After reduction of NLC there will be pain afterwards; (8) NLC might be associated with sleep disruption; (9) NLC is associated with medication use / comorbidity; (10) NLC might be associated with distress. The designated criteria for inclusion were established by more than 50% of the respondents. Geriatric experts were randomly chosen on the basis of their expertise in geriatric health.
After completing the systematic search and manual searches of the reference lists of the systematic reviews and narrative reviews and after removing duplicates and records not meeting the inclusion criteria, in the screening a total of 221 papers were yielded of which 162 were irrelevant and had to be excluded due to not meeting titles and abstracts. This resulted in 59 records that were appropriate for further evaluation. Subsequently, 41 full-text articles were excluded because they did not describe diagnostic criteria of NLC in older adults. No primary studies with the focus on diagnosing were found. Eight randomised clinical trials and ten observational studies were eligible for analysing classification characteristics of NLC. Full consensus between MHG and WPK was reached regarding the included citations. Figure 1 presents the selection of the studies through the review process.
The groups were treated equally in all studies, and the randomisation procedure was performed well, except in one instance. Among the observational studies two showed low risk of bias [4, 16]. In all studies, the populations were well defined.
The total number of participants in the 18 included studies was 36,515 of which the study of Garrison et al. 2015 included 31,339 participants. Overall, 51% of the participants were male and mean age of participants was 64 years (range 51-75 years).
Comorbidities were categorized in five domains:
Heart and vascular diseases: coronary artery disease, peripheral vascular disease, hypertension, varicose veins, ankle oedema, vascular occlusive disease and leg claudication.
Kidney diseases: renal dialysis, haemodialysis, uraemia, hypocalcaemia and hypokalaemia.
Neurological diseases: neuropathies, motor neuron disease, radiculopathy or hereditary cramp syndromes, neuromuscular or neurological diseases, peripheral neuropathy, Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis, poliomyelitis, lumbar spinal radiculopathy, lumbar canal stenosis and stroke.
Musculoskeletal disorders: arthritis and myopathies.
Metabolic disorders: Diabetes Mellitus, plasma electrolyte abnormalities hepatic, liver cirrhosis, postphlebitic syndrome volume depletion, hyponatremia, hypothyroidism, hyper- and hypothyroidism and acute extracellular volume depletion including excessive perspiration.
The analysis of 18 primary studies revealed twelve different diagnostic criteria used: ‘rest, sleep or night’ (n = 16); ‘painful’ (n = 12); ‘aged > 50’ (n = 8); ‘involuntary’ (n = 10); ‘sudden onset’ (n = 7; ‘posterior calf, foot or thigh’ (n = 8); ‘sleep disruption’ (n = 7); ‘persisting pain afterwards’ (n = 4); ‘duration from seconds to several minutes’ (n = 5); ‘distress’ (n = 4); ‘stiffness’ (n = 1) and ‘asymmetrical cramps’ (n = 1) [4, 9, 14–27].
Clinical classification characteristics
After counting the number of times the criteria were described, and after comparing the twelve criteria to RLS and PLMD criteria, the following criteria were deemed not distinctive enough: ‘at rest or sleep’, ‘aged’, ‘involuntary’, ‘sudden onset’, ‘stiffness’ and ‘asymmetrical’. As a result, the following seven criteria remained in order to differentiate NLC from RLS and PLMD: ‘pain’, ‘intense pain’, ‘period of seconds to a maximum of 10 minutes’, ‘located in posterior calf or foot’, ‘subsequent pain’, ‘sleep disruption’ and ‘distress’. These seven classification characteristics differentiate from RLS and PLMD See Table 4.
This review has identified seven criteria, derived from consensus, which can be employed as a framework to differentiate NLC from RLS or PLMD.
Distress and sleep disruption are indicated in a limited number of studies and are associated with negative impacts on physically related aspects of the quality of life . Similarly, ‘subsequent pain’ is also a criterion as a consequence of the occurrence of NLC. The NLC characteristics that were revealed as the most discriminatory – compared to those of RLS and PLMD – include intense pain with duration of a maximum of ten minutes in the calf or the foot, with relief of the symptoms occurring with no intervention. In contrast to NLC, pain in rest or during sleep in the calf or foot can also be due to vascular insufficiency.
In contrast to previous studies, that included all kind of cramps in different ages, the current review focused on NLC among older adults aging 50 years and older therefore excludes other types of cramps [1–3, 28]. Naylor et al. 1994, showed the highest prevalence of NLC is in age group 60-69 years, which is in line with our result with a mean age of the total population in the included studies of 64 years . We also confirmed the previous findings that vascular and renal comorbidities are the most stated and are clinically relevant in elderly people [4, 9, 19–21, 25, 27, 29]. In addition, the use of diuretics is known to cause muscle cramps [9, 16, 21, 24–26, 29]. Consequently, we suggest that vascular and renal comorbidities as well as the use of diuretics could be considered as correlational factors for NLC. This may improve the accuracy of future NLC diagnoses.
Managing the symptoms of patients with NLC can be a challenge in daily clinical practice considering how recent some developments in the diagnosis and treatment of the disorder are. Therefore, we suggest that these developments indicate extending the scope of clinical care. The framework introduced in this review provides a natural guide to future research within the population of older adults with musculoskeletal disorders during rest or sleep. Further research on the reliability and validation of the proposed theoretical framework is necessary for clinical application and diagnostic accuracy.
In addition, two clinical test procedures were reported for diagnostic application: the forceful knee flexion test indicated findings of cramps; the examiner applies a force to overcome knee flexion when testing in a prone position. Most patients with lumbar disc herniation comorbid with leg cramps also showed positive findings during this test, and cramps could be induced (n = 2) [26, 30]. There is a need for diagnostic studies in regard to these clinical tests on NLC and it will be interesting to assess their benefits as well [26, 30].
A potential limitation of this review is the lack of primary studies with the focus on diagnosing NLC in older adults. Therefore, as much as possible, the risk of bias was limited by using clearly defined inclusion criteria and conducting a thorough screening and reviewing process of the presented literature. Inherent in this process was the inclusion of patients with several comorbidities in the separate studies. Although these comorbidities might have influenced the interpretation of NLC, it does reflect the clinical relevance of patients with this disorder.
An extensive history taking including the above seven characteristics may rule out other disorders in diagnosing idiopathic NLC. In conclusion, seven relevant clinical characteristics have been identified to diagnose patients with NLC, and specifically differentiate this disorder from RLS and PLMD. These characteristics enhance the recognition and diagnosis of this highly prevalent, musculoskeletal sleep-related disorder.
Nocturnal leg cramps
Periodic limb movement disorder
Restless leg syndrome
Allen RE, Kirby KA. Nocturnal leg cramps. Am Fam Physician. 2012;86:350–5.
Garrison SR, Allan GM, Sekhon RK, Musini VM, Khan KM. Magnesium for skeletal muscle cramps. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012;12(9):CD009402.
Monderer RS, Wu WP, Thorpy MJ. Nocturnal leg cramps. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep. 2010;10:53–9.
Hawke F, Chuter V, Burns J. Impact of nocturnal calf cramping on quality of sleep and health-related quality of life. Qual Life Res. 2013;22:1281–6.
Coppin RJ, Wicke DM, Little PS. Managing nocturnal leg cramps--calf-stretching exercises and cessation of quinine treatment: a factorial randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract. 2005;55:186–91.
El-Tawil S, Al Musa T, Valli H, Lunn MP, El-Tawil T, Weber M, et al. Quinine for muscle cramps. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;12:CD005044.
Bahk JW, Kim H, Jung-Choi K, Jung MC, Lee I. Relationship between prolonged standing and symptoms of varicose veins and nocturnal leg cramps among women and men. Ergonomics. 2012;55:133–9.
Imura T, Inoue G, Nakazawa T, Miyagi M, Saito W, et al. Treatment of nocturnal leg cramps by blockade of the medial branch of the deep peroneal nerve after lumbar spine surgery. Brain Behav. 2015;5:00370.
Hallegraeff JM, van der Schans CP, de Ruiter R, de Greef MH. Stretching before sleep reduces the frequency and severity of nocturnal leg cramps in older adults: a randomised trial. J Physiother. 2012;58:17–22.
Hallegraeff JM, Greef MH, Schans CP. A clear definition of nocturnal leg cramps is essential for comparability of research. J Physiother. 2014;60:174–5.
Allen RP, Picchietti DL, Garcia-Borreguero D, Ondo WG, Walters AS, International Restless Legs Syndrome Study Group, et al. Restless legs syndrome/Willis-Ekbom disease diagnostic criteria: updated International Restless Legs Syndrome Study Group (IRLSSG) consensus criteria--history, rationale, description, and significance. Sleep Med. 2014;15:860–73.
Morin CM, Espie CA. The Oxford Handbook of Sleep and Sleep Disorders. New York: Oxford University Press; 2012.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ. 2009;21:339. b2535.
Serrao M, Rossi P, Cardinali P, Valente G, Parisi L, et al. Treatment for muscle cramps: an open-label trial. Clin Neuropharmacol. 2000;23:45–9.
Young JB, Connolly MJ. Naftidrofuryl treatment for rest cramp. Postgrad Med J. 1993;69:624–6.
Garrison SR, Dormuth CR, Morrow RL, Carney GA, Khan KM. Nocturnal leg cramps and prescription use that precedes them: a sequence symmetry analysis. Arch Intern Med. 2012;172:120–6.
Garrison SR, Birmingham CL, Koehler BE, McCollom RA, Khan KM. The effect of magnesium infusion on rest cramps: randomized controlled trial. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2011;66:661–6.
Jansen PH, Veenhuizen KC, Wesseling AI, de Boo T, Verbeek AL. Randomised controlled trial of hydroquinine in muscle cramps. Lancet. 1997;349:528–32.
Roffe C, Sills S, Crome P, Jones P. Randomised, cross-over, placebo controlled trial of magnesium citrate in the treatment of chronic persistent leg cramps. Med Sci Monit. 2002;8:326–30.
Angeli P, Albino G, Carraro P, Dalla Pria M, Merkel C, et al. Cirrhosis and muscle cramps: evidence of a causal relationship. Hepatology. 1996;23:264–73.
Baskol M, Ozbakir O, Coşkun R, Baskol G, Saraymen R, et al. The role of serum zinc and other factors on the prevalence of muscle cramps in non-alcoholic cirrhotic patients. J Clin Gastroenterol. 2004;38:524–9.
Garrison SR, Dormuth CR, Morrow RL, Carney GA, Khan KM. Seasonal effects on the occurrence of nocturnal leg cramps: a prospective cohort study. CMAJ. 2015;3(187):248–53.
Hawke F, Chuter V, Burns J. Factors associated with night-time calf muscle cramps: a case-control study. Muscle Nerve. 2013;47:339–43.
Hirai M. Prevalence and characteristics of muscle cramps in patients with varicose veins. Vasa. 2000;4:269–73.
Naylor JR, Young JB. A general population survey of rest cramps. Age Ageing. 1994;5:418–20.
Nishant, Chhabra HS, Kapoor KS. Nocturnal cramps in patients with lumbar spinal canal stenosis treated conservatively: a prospective study. Asian Spine J. 2014;85:624–31.
Oboler SK, Prochazka AV, Meyer TJ. Leg symptoms in outpatient veterans. West J Med. 1991;155:256–9.
Rana AQ, Khan F, Mosabbir A, Ondo W. Differentiating nocturnal leg cramps and restless legs syndrome. Expert Rev Neurother. 2014;14:813–8.
Connolly PS, Shirley EA, Wasson JH, Nierenberg DW. Treatment of nocturnal leg cramps. A crossover trial of quinine vs vitamin E. Arch Intern Med. 1992;152:877–80.
Demircan MN, Colak A, Kutlay M, Kibici K, Topuz K. Cramp finding: can it be used as a new diagnostic and prognostic factor in lumbar disc surgery? Eur Spine J. 2002;11:47–51.
The content is solely the responsibility of the authors, who have all made substantial contributions to the study’s conception and design, the analysis and interpretation of the data, the draft and revision of the article and the final approval of the version to be submitted. Mrs A. Hartman of the University library optimized the search strategy. Also thanks to Mrs A. White and Mr D. White who edited the manuscript and improved English expression.
This project did not receive any funding.
Availability of data and materials
The full list of extracted abstracts with reasons for exclusion may be obtained from the corresponding author.
JMH conceived and coordinated the review, participated in search design and analysis, and drafted the manuscript. JMH designed the search strategy in collaboration of the library of Hanze University and reviewed the manuscript. MHG, WP and CvdS contributed to the writing and review of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors, JMH, MHG, WP and CvdS, declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study has reviewed research materials already published in the public domain, and with no contact with human subjects; therefore it was exempt from review by Hanze University Groningen.