From: Primary care nurses’ performance in motivational interviewing: a quantitative descriptive study
Behavior countsa | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Primary care nurses | Length of coded part of the sessionb (minutes) | Length of session (minutes) | Giving information | MI Adherent (MiA) | MI Non-adherent (MiNa) | Closed questions (cq) | Open questions (oq) | Simple reflections (sr) | Complex reflections (cr) |
Session | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III | I/II/III |
Nurse 1 | 20/20/20 | 51/51/54 | 18/20/22 | 2d/0/5d | 0/0/1 | 24e/15/15 | 19/21/13 | 24/33/20 | 15/21/15 |
Nurse 2 | 20/20/20 | 54/50/48 | 15/18/14 | 5e/1/2d | 0/0/0 | 16e/20e/12e | 9/8/7 | 13e/6e/4 | 6/5/5 |
Nurse 3 | 20/20/c | 24/42/c | 15/15/c | 7d/1/c | 6/2/c | 12/14/c | 3/3/c | 6d/10/c | 13/15/c |
Nurse 4 | 14/20/20 | 21/41/84 | 10/17/15 | 1/3e/1e | 1/7/6 | 14e/15e/9 | 8/7/10 | 8d/10d/3d | 12/12/8 |
Nurse 5 | 18/20/20 | 30/44/40 | 21/22/21 | 4/5d/1e | 2/4/6 | 15e/21e/15 | 8/17/12 | 10d/7/8e | 15/6/5 |
Nurse 6 | 17/20/c | 20/26/c | 4/28/ c | 1e/2/c | 3/0/c | 17 e /7 e / c | 5/8/c | 10/9/c | 3/2/c |
Nurse 7 | 11/11/19 | 13/17/30 | 14/10/30 | 2e/1e/0 | 4/8/7 | 20/14e/11 | 8/8/2 | 2d/2d/2 | 11/4/7 |
Nurse 8 | 14/20/20 | 21/22/21 | 22/35/46 | 3/5d/2e | 3/4/5 | 14/49/33 e | 3/6/5 | 7/13/7d | 5/12/17 |
Nurse 9 | 18/16/18 | 24/22/23 | 17/23/34 | 8/10d/5 | 3/2/7 | 12 e /22 e /21 e | 9/15/3 | 4d/3/8 | 8/3/1 |
Nurse 10 | 20/20/20 | 36/23/23 | 0/18/15 | 1e/2e/1e | 9/6/5 | 8/30 e /20 e | 7/5/6 | 8 d /18/7 | 5/7/8 |
Nurse 11 | 20/20/c | 30/31/c | 21/14/c | 0e/2e/c | 17/5/ c | 20 e /38 e / c | 7/5/c | 7/12/c | 2/2/c |
Nurse 12 | 20/20/c | 37/29/c | 3/48/ c | 3/5e/c | 2/9/c | 16 e /26 e / c | 8/5/c | 3e/3e/c | 0/0/c |
Summary of self-ratings of performance | Number of Sessions/Number of Nurses | ||||||||
Self-ratings | More MiA/oq/cr than MiNa/cq/sr | 9/6 | 11/7 | 2/2 | |||||
As many MiA/oq/cr as MiNa/cq/sr | 13/9 | 13/9 | 11/6 | ||||||
More MiNa/cq/sr than MiA/oq/cr | 6/5 | 5/5 | 16/10 | ||||||
Self-ratings compared with counts | Overestimates | 14/9 | 21/11 | 5/3 | |||||
Underestimates | 7/6 | 0 | 10/7 |