Skip to main content

Table 2 Effect estimates for the comparisons concerning supervised group PA

From: Interventions aimed at increasing the level of physical activity by including organised follow-up: a systematic review of effect

Study

Outcome

Participants (studies)

Comparison

Effect measure

Follow-up period/s

Effect estimate

Quality of the documentation

Isaacs [17] Strength, fitness

Minutes of PA/week

305 (1)

Advice

% change from BL (95% CI)

Post-treatment

−13% (−29, 8)

Low1,2

610 (1)

3 months

7% (−6, 22)

Low1,2

Energy expenditure kcal/kg/week

305 (1)

% change from BL (95% CI)

Post-treatment

−7% (−24, 14)

Low1,2

610 (1)

3 months

7% (−6, 23)

Low1,2

Isaacs [17] Walks

Minutes of PA/week

305 (1)

Advice

% change from BL (95% CI)

Post-treatment

19% (−4, 48)

Low1,2

610 (1)

3 months

17% (3, 34)

Low1,2

Energy expenditure kcal/kg/week

305 (1)

% change from BL (95% CI)

Post-treatment

18% (−4, 45)

Low1,2

610 (1)

3 months

19% (4, 36)

Low1,2

Park [18]

MET-adjusted minutes of PA/week

40 (1)

No treatment

Mean diff, p-value

Post-treatment

1050, ns

Very low1,3

  1. Legend: PA = physical activity; MET = metabolic equivalent of task, BL = baseline, ns = not significant; 1unclear risk of bias at study level, 2only one study, 3only one small study.