Skip to main content

Table 4 Studies by provider and type of intervention and outcome for SNAPW and health literacy

From: Which providers can bridge the health literacy gap in lifestyle risk factor modification education: a systematic review and narrative synthesis

Provider (No. of studies)

Intervention type (No. of studies)

Intervention Intensity

SNAPW outcomes (No. studies sig outcome/no studies measure SNAPW)

Health Literacy (No. studies sig outcome/No. studies measure HL)

Doctor (9)

 

H

M

L

NR

S

N

A

P

W

 
 

Motivational interviewing or counselling (5)

  

3

2

1/1

0

0

2/4

0

3/5

 

Mixed intervention (3)

 

2

  

0

1/1

0

0/1

0

0/2

 

Written material (2)

  

2

 

1/1

1/1

0

0

0

0/2

 

Total

 

2

5

2

2/2

2/2

0

2/5

0

3/9

Nurse (5) Dietician (1) or Educator (6)

Group education (4)

3

1

  

0/1

1/1

0

1/1

0

4/4

 

Motivational interviewing or counselling (5)

2

1

2

 

1/2

0

0

4/4

0/1

4/5

 

Mixed intervention (2)

1

 

1

 

0

1/1

0

0/1

0/1

2/2

 

Telephone (1)

1

   

0

0

0

1/1

0

1/1

 

Total

7

2

3

 

1/3

2/2

0

6/7

0/2

11/12

Computer (7)

           
 

Computer (2)

  

2

 

0/1

2/2

0

1/1

0

1/2

 

Computer gen written material (5)

  

5

 

3/4

3/4

0

0/1

0

4/5

 

Total

  

7

 

3/5

5/6

0

1/2

0

5/7

Lay worker (6)

           
 

Group education (5)

3

1

 

1

0

2/3

0

2/4

1/1

3/5

 

Mixed intervention (1)

1

   

1/1

1/1

0

1/1

0

0/1

 

Total

4

1

 

1

1/1

3/4

0

3/4

1/1

3/6

Other (7)

           
 

Mixed intervention (1)

1

   

0/1

1/1

0/1

0/1

0

1/1

 

Telephone (1)

 

1

  

0

0

0

0

0

1/1

 

Written (5)

 

3

2

 

0

3/3

0

3/5

0/1

4/5

 

Total

1

4

2

 

0/1

4/4

0/1

3/6

0/1

6/7

MDT (11)

           
 

Group education (5)

2

3

  

0/1

3/3

0

2/2

1/2

5/5

 

Mixed intervention (5)

2

2

1

 

1/1

1/2

0

1/2

2/2

4/5

 

Motivational interviewing and counselling (1)

 

1

  

0

0

0

1/1

0

1/1

 

Total

4

6

1

 

1/2

4/5

0

4/5

3/4

10/11